1936th BLOG POST
21st
Book of 2021
As
all of you know that Bhagavad Gita is one of my favourite passion and I just
love going to it whenever I feel doubtful, sad, clueless, and directionless.
Every page of it has an essence that ends up giving you the motivation and
meaning you are looking forward to. I find many people talking about the
purpose of life. Most of them say just for the sake of it but the people who
really wish to seek the meaning of this question tend to turn towards Bhagavad
Gita and get the answer they were searching for. The biggest question arises
for people when they wish to get into the reading of Bhagavad Gita is – Which
is the original Bhagavad Gita and which will give me the best and real meaning
of it. This happens because almost all the books are translated and explained
by different authors hence a person finds it hard to find the real Bhagavad
Gita.
All
the problems a reader faces in searching a Gita and then understanding it is
discussed in this new book I just completed reading after 4 months. It is named
“Aksara Bhagavad Gita” written by the combo of father and daughter – Haribakth
and Vaishnavi. Haribakth is the pen name of Mr. Ravindra Rao. Before this, I
read the book called “19th Akshauhini: Algorithm of the Gita” written by the
same father-daughter duo and it was surely a new experience for me. Haribakth
writes every book from a research point of view which sounds like published
papers by big Universities of the world. I like the way all the points are
articulated and summarized in all the chapters.
The
book is of around 600 pages, and it needs a lot of patience for the reader to
finish reading it. If you have ever wondered why we find contradiction in
several shlokas of Gita (or we perceive it in such manner), then the whole
effort of this book is to ensure you understand them well along with the context
of it. It has been written in a
conversational discussion mode between the two characters- like the tone in
which the original Bhagavad Gita is written. A character asks questions related
to her queries on Bhagavad Gita which is then provided as a detailed answer by
another character resolving all the doubts and problems. I liked how the
characters are evolved from the authors’ 1st book and anyone who has
read that will feel nostalgic.
You
will start feeling the arrival of the main content of the book from the chapter
named “Navaratri Conversation” which speaks about lot of subjects such as how
Gita is read, heard, and understood from a semantic perspective but not from
conceptual perspective – why only God narrated the Gita and not entrusted upon
someone else for the same – Juxtaposition – Dharma – Surrender – Liberation –
Sins - Sacrifices – Knowledge and
Silence – God on Memory – Shunya and its reference with God – examples of
syllogism in the Gita etc. There are many other ideologies that the author
discusses in this chapter giving reference of the chapters which shall arrive
in the future in the book. This is basically like a precap of the whole book.
In case you don’t have time, you can go through this section itself and you are
done knowing a lot of things about Gita and its correct perception.
After
this – author begins the real debate and names all the chapters in this section
as Kurukshetra. I liked this metaphor as the Gita was actually spoken on the
ground of Kurukshetra or say, the Kurukshetra War, and even here in the book,
the chapters with real debate on all the main pointers are named as
Kurukshetra. This segment discusses many primary teachings of Gita. Author
gives many references of how the God is Supreme and no one is beyond him but He
is beyond everyone. I liked how author gives the example and reasoning of
Algebra to discuss the topic of Perishable vs Imperishable. Author also
provides many pointers to state why Gita is complete and self-contained. The
book also talks about definition of different concepts such as Spiritual and
Mundane, Temporary and Permanent, Crime and Sin etc. Author also talks in
detail about one of the important aspects discussed in Gita i.e. three types of
Guna – Sattva, Rajas and Tamas. We are also explained the concept of how God is
the cause of all actions, gunas – the performer and we – just the medium
through which the action is performed.
There
are many such explanation, detailing and learnings that are provided through
this book which will make your hold on Gita and its messaging more solid and
powerful. I liked the tables at the end or between of every chapter which helps
in understanding the summary of the section in a very professional manner. The
pointers/bullets used throughout the book emphasize every point that the debate
discussions need to make. Generally, as a reader, we make notes of all the
important points in the book but here, the book is itself written in a way that
every sentence of it is important. Just like original Bhagavad Gita, you read
any page of this book, and it is going to be insightful for you and the
situation you are dealing with. Authors knew it very well how to entertain and
inform the readers who are seeking knowledge on Bhagavad Gita and the book is
drafted in a very mature manner in the same way.
Talking
about the drawbacks of the book, I must say that the length of the book is the
biggest concern. This could have either be divided into two different parts so
that it could motivate readers to pick it up because a book with 600-pages in
such busy life is always going to be a tough decision to read. Secondly, the
pricing of the book is on a very high side. I believe it should also be cut
short. Thirdly, I must say that the book doesn’t provide a consistent way of
writing as you find dialogues in between, then debates, then suddenly pointers
and unexpectedly, a table format inserted between them. Author could have
worked a little on that front.
Overall,
this is a book which I believe you can pick only after you have little
knowledge on what Gita is; or even if you have read easier version of Gita by
Indian authors. I give this extremely researched and nicely compiled book 4.5
stars out of 5. Recommended to everyone who loves reading Gita or seeks to know
the answer on What is God or What is the Purpose of Life.
Thanks.
WRITING BUDDHA
2 CoMMenTs !!! - U CaN aLSo CoMMenT !!!:
beautifully detailed review. Anyone thinking of buying this book should see this review.
Hari OM
Ah - but for me there is no rendition that can improve on that given by HH Pujya Gurudev Sw Chinmayananda... a mahatama with solid parampara from which lineage I have been taught and now teach. (That is whole-book form, but it can also be purchased as chapter format to spread cost.)
The writing of this father/daughter you review today may well be worthy, but it will be informed only by their own thinking. An interpretation.
The 'real' Gita is the Sanskrit version pulled from the Mahabharata; if one reads Sanskrit then one can take meaning for oneself. Even then, to have a teacher with proper authority is necessary - just as with any subject we choose to study in depth. The professors have their tenures for a reason... YAM xx
Post a Comment